Overall Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (3.75/5 Stars)
Spice Rating: 🔥🔥🔥🔥 (4/5 - Hot and Intense)
Plot Rating: 📚📚📚 (3/5 - Intriguing but Inconsistent)
The Setup: Joker Meets Haunting Adeline in a Prison Setting
"Toxic" by Nicole Blanchard is a book that will have you simultaneously gripping your Kindle and scratching your head in confusion. It's a rollercoaster that starts thrilling, takes you through intense loops, and then suddenly veers off into a completely different theme park. Despite its flaws, there's something undeniably compelling about this chaotic story that kept me reading.
The premise is deliciously dark: a prison nurse trapped in an abusive marriage who finds herself drawn to a dangerous inmate. It's forbidden, twisted, and promises all the dark romance goodness fans crave. The first half delivers on that promise. But then... well, we'll get to that.
Plot Summary: From Prison Walls to... Wait, Where Are We Going?
Tessa Emmerson is a 27-year-old registered nurse at Blackthorne Correctional Institute, a high-security prison. Her life is a carefully constructed facade hiding a horrifying reality: she's married to Vic, the prison warden, who is a violent, sadistic abuser. Tessa's days are a monotonous cycle of survival—go to work, avoid triggering her husband's rage, endure the abuse, repeat. She's tried to escape before, even pressed charges, but the system failed her when a judge dismissed her case.
Tessa has learned to make herself invisible, blending into the background at work and home. She walks on eggshells constantly, knowing one wrong move could result in another beating. Her husband controls every aspect of her life. She's trapped in a prison of her own, even more confining than the one where she works.
Everything changes when a new inmate arrives. He's listed as John Doe initially, but his real name is Gracin Kingsley—though everyone calls him King. He's classified as high-risk and dangerous. When Tessa treats him in the infirmary, their first encounter is electric. King sees her—really sees her—in a way no one else does. He notices the bruises, the fear, the way she flinches. Unlike everyone else who ignores the signs of abuse, King calls it out.
"How is it possible that one man, someone who is supposed to uphold the law can tear me down, and another who is supposed to be the scum of the earth, build me up," Tessa reflects.
King gets assigned to work in the infirmary, giving him daily access to Tessa. Their interactions are charged with tension—part attraction, part danger, part something neither can name. King draws pictures of Tessa, leaving them for her to find. He makes her feel seen, valued, and desired in ways her husband never has.
"C'mon," King coaxes. "Let me give you this. One kiss. I promise you'll enjoy it. Let me show you a little something sweet to take away from the sour. One kiss, and if you want me to walk away after, I will."
One kiss is never just one kiss. The attraction explodes into something consuming and dangerous. The chemistry between Tessa and King is palpable, intense, and absolutely forbidden.
But here's where the story takes its first major turn. King orchestrates a prison break, and Tessa helps him escape. A confrontation with Vic leads to violence and Tessa shooting her abusive husband. What follows is a frantic escape.
The prison romance becomes something else entirely. Tessa escapes from King (yes, she escapes from the man she helped escape), and the story transforms into cat-and-mouse. She tries to start a new life in Los Angeles, gets new documents with surprising ease, and attempts to disappear. But King finds her.
Then the plot takes another sharp turn. King isn't just some criminal—he's actually a highly skilled hitman. And Tessa? She gets kidnapped by people looking for King, is brutally tortured, and loses a baby she didn't know she was carrying (yes, there are multiple pregnancies and miscarriages in this book).
The final act sees Tessa transform from meek, abused woman into something resembling Rambo with a nursing degree. She develops survival skills, becomes hardened, and somehow ends up in a relationship with King that the book insists is love, though the emotional development is questionable.
Character Deep Dive: From Victims to... Something Else
Tessa Emmerson: A Character Arc That Defies Physics
Tessa starts as a deeply sympathetic character trapped in an abusive marriage. The book doesn't shy away from depicting the brutal reality of domestic violence. The abuse scenes are graphic, uncomfortable, and unfortunately realistic. Tessa's fear, her survival mechanisms, her inability to simply "just leave"—all portrayed with rawness that readers will find either powerful or triggering.
"What is broken inside me that I look for love in the worst places?" Tessa wonders. "Am I just so fucked up that I'll take affection wherever I can get it, even if it's from the worst possible source?"
This internal questioning is one of the book's strengths. Tessa's self-awareness about her patterns adds depth. She's not naive—she's desperate, traumatized, and grasping at any lifeline, even if that lifeline comes with its own dangers.
The problem is that Tessa's character development happens in jarring transitions that don't make sense. She goes from barely standing up to her husband to shooting him without hesitation. Then she becomes resourceful enough to steal a truck, break into houses, and create a new identity. Finally, she transforms into someone with assassin-level survival skills, all without any training or explanation.
One reviewer perfectly captured this: "Tessa went from a fragile, never left home, battered wife to someone easily accessing fake identities, to full blown assassin with absolutely no explanation." The character development isn't an arc—it's a series of quantum leaps that leave readers with whiplash.
Gracin "King" Kingsley: The Man of Many Faces
King is introduced as a dangerous inmate with a mysterious past. He's got that classic dark romance hero vibe—pierced (in special places), tattooed, dangerous, and possessing an intensity that's both attractive and terrifying. He's observant, protective, and obsessed in that way dark romance heroes tend to be.
"You think you don't want this?" he asks. "You shouldn't want me. I am not a nice man. I am not a good man. I do bad things for bad people. I want to do bad things to you."
This is classic morally gray hero territory, and for the first part, it works. King is compelling, mysterious, and his interest in Tessa feels genuine, if intense. The problem is that King's character undergoes jarring transformations that don't always track.
We learn he's actually a professional assassin who got himself thrown in prison on purpose (using his real name, which... okay). His obsession with Tessa goes from protective to possessive to borderline kidnapper. He tells her he won't let her go, that he'll keep her in his mansion forever, that she belongs to him.
"I wouldn't let you go, but I'd spend every day convincing you to stay," he says, which sounds romantic until you remember he's literally keeping her prisoner at various points.
King suffers from "plot-driven personality disorder"—his actions shift to serve whatever the plot needs rather than flowing naturally from established character. Is he a protective hero? A dangerous villain? A romantic lead? A kidnapper? The answer seems to be "yes, all of the above, depending on what chapter you're reading."
The Dynamic: Toxic by Name, Toxic by Nature
The relationship between Tessa and King is, as the title suggests, toxic. But it's not always clear whether we're supposed to see it as toxic or as some twisted form of true love. The book wants it both ways—acknowledging the dysfunction while also romanticizing it.
Their chemistry is undeniable. The sexual tension is palpable. When they finally give in, the scenes are hot, intense, and well-written. But the emotional connection that would make this relationship feel like more than just lust and trauma bonding never quite develops.
"What we have is dangerous and volatile, but it's also inevitable," the book tells us. But is it? Or is it just two damaged people clinging to each other because they're both running from something?
The book tries to sell us on the idea that they're soulmates, that their connection is deep and meaningful. But what we actually see is sexual attraction, some protective behavior from King, and Tessa repeatedly trying to escape from him. That's not a love story—that's Stockholm syndrome with better abs.
Tropes That Make This Book What It Is
Forbidden Romance: Prison nurse and dangerous inmate—as forbidden as it gets.
Domestic Violence/Abuse Survivor: Tessa's abusive marriage is central. The book doesn't romanticize the abuse from her husband, though some might argue it romanticizes the dysfunction with King.
Morally Gray Hero: King is supposed to be morally gray, though he veers into morally black. He's a hitman, a kidnapper, and someone who makes decisions for Tessa without her consent.
Touch Her and Die: King is very much in the "touch her and you'll die" camp. He's possessive and protective, sometimes to an uncomfortable degree.
Forced Proximity: Whether in the prison infirmary or later in King's mansion, these two spend a lot of time in close quarters.
On the Run: After the prison break, they become fugitives, adding suspense to the romance.
Pregnancy/Miscarriage: This book features three pregnancies and two miscarriages. It's a lot, and it happens very quickly.
Transformation Arc: Tessa goes from victim to survivor to something else entirely. The transformation is dramatic, if not always believable.
Obsessive Love: King's obsession with Tessa drives much of the plot.
Cat and Mouse: Tessa repeatedly tries to escape, and King repeatedly finds her.
Trigger Warnings: This Book Goes Dark
This is a dark romance that earns that label. Readers should be aware of:
- Graphic Domestic Violence: Explicit, disturbing depictions of physical beatings, emotional abuse, and coercion.
- Sexual Assault/Rape: Scenes of marital rape and non-consensual sex. Tessa says "no" multiple times in one scene, and King proceeds anyway.
- Kidnapping and Captivity: Multiple instances of characters being held against their will.
- Torture: Tessa is brutally tortured.
- Pregnancy Loss/Miscarriage: Two miscarriages, one as a result of violence.
- Murder and Violence: Multiple deaths, some graphic.
- Manipulation and Coercion: Emotional manipulation throughout.
- Dubious Consent: Several sexual encounters have questionable consent.
- Trauma and PTSD: Characters dealing with severe trauma.
This is not a book for readers sensitive to these topics. The author includes trigger warnings at the beginning, which readers should take seriously.
What Works: The Strengths of "Toxic"
The First Half is Genuinely Compelling
When "Toxic" focuses on the prison setting and forbidden attraction between Tessa and King, it's actually quite good. The tension is palpable, the stakes feel real, and the dynamic is interesting. The author does an excellent job building sexual tension and creating that sense of dangerous attraction that makes dark romance appealing. The prison setting creates a pressure cooker atmosphere that makes every interaction feel charged and significant.
The Abuse is Not Romanticized
One thing the book does right is its portrayal of Tessa's abusive marriage. The abuse from Vic is never presented as romantic or acceptable. It's shown for what it is: brutal, dehumanizing, and traumatic. He's a monster, and the narrative treats him as such. This creates a clear distinction between the abuse Tessa suffers from her husband and the dysfunction in her relationship with King.
The Writing is Engaging
Nicole Blanchard can write. Her prose is clear, engaging, and moves at a good pace. Even when the plot makes questionable choices, the sentence-level writing is solid. The sex scenes are well-written and hot, the action sequences are easy to follow.
The Heat is Real
If you're here for steamy scenes, "Toxic" delivers. The sexual chemistry between Tessa and King is off the charts, and when they finally act on that attraction, the scenes are scorching. The book earns its spice rating with explicit, detailed sex scenes that are both hot and emotionally charged.
What Doesn't Work: The Weaknesses That Hold It Back
The Plot Has More Holes Than Swiss Cheese
The plot of "Toxic" doesn't always make sense. Characters make decisions that defy logic, plot points are introduced and abandoned, and the story takes sharp turns that feel more like the author changing her mind mid-draft than organic development.
For example: King is supposed to be an elite assassin, but he gets himself thrown in prison using his real name? His escape plan involves starting a riot and walking out? No one checks the security footage that would clearly show Tessa helping him? And Tessa suddenly knows how to create fake identities and disappear?
One reviewer nailed it: "What elite, loaded assassin uses his real freaking name to get thrown in jail with every intention of escaping? Even I know better than that."
Character Development is Inconsistent
Both main characters undergo dramatic transformations that happen so abruptly they feel jarring rather than earned. Tessa goes from meek victim to action hero with no training or gradual development. King goes from mysterious inmate to professional killer to obsessive lover, and we're just supposed to roll with it.
"This book had no transitions or character development," one reviewer complained. "It literally felt like the author wrote 5 different books and just kept the character names the same."
The Romance Lacks Emotional Depth
Here's the biggest problem: for a romance novel, there's surprisingly little actual romance. There's lust, obsession, trauma bonding, but not much genuine emotional connection or relationship development.
Tessa and King go from barely knowing each other to being willing to kill for each other, but we never see the emotional journey that would make that believable. They have chemistry, but chemistry alone doesn't make a romance. When Tessa suddenly announces she's in love with King near the end, it feels unearned because we haven't seen that love develop.
The Pacing is All Over the Place
The first half moves at a measured pace, building tension and developing the forbidden attraction. Then suddenly, everything happens at once—prison break, murder, escape, kidnapping, torture, miscarriage, transformation, and resolution—all crammed into the second half. It's exhausting and leaves you feeling like you've been through a blender.
The ending feels particularly rushed. After all the chaos, everything wraps up very quickly. Suddenly they're in love, suddenly there's a trial, suddenly they're living happily ever after.
The Consent Issues are Problematic
While the book doesn't romanticize the abuse from Tessa's husband, it has serious consent issues with King. There's a scene where Tessa explicitly says "no" multiple times, and King proceeds anyway. The book tries to frame this as passion overcoming resistance, but it's sexual assault.
This is particularly problematic because the book seems to want us to see King as the "good" alternative to Vic, but a man who ignores a woman's explicit refusal is not a hero, morally gray or otherwise.
The Verdict: A Messy But Occasionally Compelling Read
"Toxic" had a lot of potential but doesn't quite stick the landing. The premise is intriguing, the first half is genuinely engaging, and there are moments of real intensity and heat. But the second half loses the plot (literally), the character development is inconsistent, and the romance never quite gels into something believable.
This is a book for readers who:
- Love dark romance and aren't bothered by problematic content
- Can overlook plot holes in favor of intensity and heat
- Enjoy prison romance settings
- Want a fast-paced, action-packed story
- Are looking for high steam content
- Can handle graphic depictions of violence and abuse
This is NOT a book for readers who:
- Are sensitive to domestic violence, sexual assault, or trauma
- Need logical, coherent plots
- Want well-developed romance with emotional depth
- Prefer gradual character development
- Want a romance that focuses on the relationship rather than external action
- Need clear consent in their romance novels
Final Thoughts: When Toxic is Truth in Advertising
"Toxic" is aptly named. The relationships are toxic, the situations are toxic, and honestly, some of the writing choices are a bit toxic too. But if you go into this book knowing what you're getting—a chaotic, intense, problematic dark romance that prioritizes heat and action over coherent plotting and emotional development—you might find something to enjoy.
The book's biggest strength is also its biggest weakness: it's unrelenting. It throws everything at you—abuse, obsession, violence, sex, action, suspense—without giving you time to breathe. For some readers, this intensity will be thrilling. For others, it will be exhausting.
I'm giving this book 3.75 stars because while it has significant flaws, it also has moments of genuine engagement. The first half is strong enough to earn those stars, and the heat level throughout is undeniable. But I can't give it higher because the second half is such a mess, and the romance—which should be the heart of any romance novel—never quite comes together.
If you're a dark romance reader willing to overlook plot inconsistencies and questionable character development in favor of intensity and heat, give "Toxic" a try. Just check those trigger warnings first, because this book earns every single one of them.
Bottom Line: "Toxic" is a dark, intense, and deeply flawed romance that starts strong but loses its way in the second half. It's got heat, intensity, and enough chaos to keep you turning pages, but it lacks the emotional depth and coherent plotting to make it truly great. Worth a read if you're a dark romance fan who can overlook significant structural issues, but don't expect a masterpiece. Just expect a wild, messy ride that lives up to its title in every possible way.
Add comment
Comments